Connecticut Town Saves $600,000 While Protecting Employee Benefits with the Difference Card
Key Takeaways A Quick Summary
Key Takeaways
- The organization avoided a 10% Anthem renewal increase and achieved a -8% decrease to current costs, delivering more than $500,000 in guaranteed annual savings through The Difference Card MERP.
- The existing medical plan structure (two Anthem HMO plans and one PPO) and copay-based benefits were preserved, minimizing disruption for employees during open enrollment.
- The MERP reimbursement strategy lowered employees' overall out-of-pocket healthcare expenses, enhancing member value without reducing benefit quality.
- The Difference Guarantee capped the employer's annual reimbursement liability for predictable budgeting; the Monthly Budget feature smoothed monthly funding; and 100% of any unused reimbursement surplus is returned to the employer.
- The partnership between Higginbotham and The Difference Card demonstrated a replicable, innovative funding approach that reduced employer healthcare spend while preserving employee choice and benefit value.
Municipal Employer in Connecticut Achieves 15% Guaranteed Healthcare Savings Through an Innovative MERP Strategy
Public sector employers across the country continue to face unprecedented healthcare cost pressures, often forcing difficult decisions between increasing taxes, reducing employee benefits, or absorbing unsustainable budget increases. For this Connecticut Town, those choices appeared inevitable after receiving an 18% health insurance renewal increase.
Instead, the Town partnered with Marsh McLennan Agency (MMA) and the Difference Card to implement an innovative healthcare funding strategy that protected taxpayers, preserved employee benefits, and generated significant guaranteed savings.
The collaborative effort between Emily Coughlin Molloy, Senior Sales Consultant for the Difference Card's Connecticut market, Shawn Hill, Public Sector Client Advisor at Marsh McLennan Agency, and Fran Gallagher, Senior Benefits Consultant at Marsh McLennan Agency, resulted in the implementation of the Difference Card's Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan (MERP) utilizing the Difference Guarantee Monthly Budget feature.
Together, the team delivered a 15% guaranteed reduction in healthcare costs, producing more than $600,000 in annual guaranteed savings while maintaining high-quality healthcare coverage for Town employees.
The Challenge
Like many municipalities throughout Connecticut, the this Town was confronted with an unsustainable healthcare renewal that threatened both its operating budget and its taxpayers.
The Town's fully insured medical program with UnitedHealthcare (UHC) was projected to increase by 18%, creating hundreds of thousands of dollars in additional healthcare costs.
Without an innovative financing strategy, municipal leadership would have been forced to consider:
- Increasing taxes to fund rising healthcare expenses
- Reducing employee benefits
- Passing additional costs to employees through higher payroll deductions
- Increasing deductibles and out-of-pocket expenses
The Town sought a solution that would preserve employee satisfaction while maintaining fiscal responsibility.
The Solution
Marsh McLennan Agency and the Difference Card designed a customized healthcare strategy centered around the Difference Card's Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan (MERP).
The new program featured a health plan design utilizing UnitedHealthcare (UHC) medical plans, allowing employees to continue accessing the same trusted provider network while giving them flexible plan choices that best fit their healthcare needs.
Rather than asking employees to sacrifice benefits, the Difference Card strategy enhanced the overall value of their healthcare coverage.
Key elements of the solution included:
- UnitedHealthcare medical plans for both active and retiree populations
- Difference Card Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan (MERP)
- Difference Guarantee Monthly Budget feature
- Guaranteed reimbursement liability for the employer
- 100% return of unused reimbursement surplus at the end of the plan year
Because employees continued using the same UnitedHealthcare provider network, there was no disruption to physician relationships or hospital access. At the same time, the MERP reimbursed eligible out-of-pocket expenses, reducing employees' financial responsibility and creating a richer overall benefit experience.
Better Benefits Without Higher Costs
One of the greatest strengths of the Difference Card approach is its ability to improve the employee experience while reducing employer healthcare costs.
For Town employees, the program delivered:
- Continued access to the existing UnitedHealthcare provider network
- Lower out-of-pocket healthcare expenses
- Improved overall plan value
- No need to change physicians or hospitals
For the Town, the Difference Guarantee Monthly Budget feature provided budget certainty by establishing a predictable monthly reimbursement amount while capping the employer's reimbursement liability. Any unused reimbursement dollars are returned to the employer at the end of the plan year, allowing the municipality to benefit from favorable claims experience rather than losing those dollars.
This combination created a healthcare financing model that was both employee-friendly and fiscally responsible.
The Results
The partnership between Marsh McLennan Agency and the Difference Card produced outstanding financial results for this Connecticut Town.
Annual Results
- 18% health insurance increase eliminated
- More than $600,000 in guaranteed annual savings
- 15% guaranteed reduction in overall healthcare costs
- Employees maintained their UnitedHealthcare provider network
- Employee out-of-pocket costs improved
- Predictable monthly healthcare budgeting through the Difference Guarantee
- No increase in local taxes needed to fund healthcare costs
The financial impact extended well beyond the employee benefits program. By offsetting what would have been an 18% renewal increase, the Town preserved valuable public resources and avoided placing additional financial burdens on local residents.
"The Difference Card solution gave us exactly what we were looking for—a way to control one of our fastest-growing budget expenses without reducing benefits for our employees or increasing taxes on our residents. The guaranteed savings and budget certainty provided through the Monthly Budget feature gave our leadership team tremendous confidence throughout the process."
— Town Finance Director
A True Partnership for Public Sector Success
The Town's success was the result of a highly collaborative partnership among Marsh McLennan Agency, the Difference Card, and Town leadership.
Fran Gallagher and Shawn Hill of Marsh McLennan Agency worked closely with Emily Coughlin Molloy throughout the evaluation, financial analysis, implementation, and employee communication process to ensure the Town selected the strategy that best aligned with its fiscal objectives and employee benefit philosophy.
By combining Marsh McLennan Agency's deep expertise in the Connecticut public sector with the Difference Card's proven MERP strategy, the team delivered a solution that improved employee benefits while producing guaranteed financial results.
Their partnership demonstrates how innovative advisors and healthcare financing specialists can work together to help municipalities overcome rising healthcare costs without compromising the quality of benefits offered to public employees.
Looking Ahead
As healthcare costs continue to rise for municipalities nationwide, innovative strategies like the Difference Card Medical Expense Reimbursement Plan are helping public employers regain control of their healthcare budgets.
For this Town, the Difference Card delivered exactly what every municipal employer hopes to achieve:
- Guaranteed savings
- Better employee benefits
- Budget predictability
- Protection for taxpayers
- Long-term healthcare sustainability
The collaboration between Marsh McLennan Agency and the Difference Card stands as another example of how trusted partnerships and innovative healthcare funding strategies can transform challenging renewals into lasting success stories for public sector employers. Through the leadership of Emily Coughlin Molloy, Shawn Hill, and Fran Gallagher, the Town now has a sustainable healthcare solution that benefits employees, municipal leadership, and taxpayers alike.
💡 Looking to help your clients reduce healthcare costs while improving their benefits offering?
👉 Contact us today to learn how our proven strategies can deliver immediate and lasting results.
